For innovation in industrial markets, if you are counting on a stage-gate® process to drive your new product development (NPD) success, I have some bad news. It probably won’t. This may come as a surprise. After all, stage-gate®—a registered trademark of the Product Development Institute, Inc. and the fruit of some fine work by Dr. Robert Cooper—has been synonymous with disciplined NPD for three decades.
To be clear, I’m a fan of using a stage-gate process as well as a fan of its inventor, Dr. Cooper. (And if you haven’t checked out his more recent work that combines his stage-gate work with agile development… you should.) But it’s best to think of your stage-gate process as “necessary but not sufficient.” You need more.
Click here to learn the 12 Steps to a Powerful New Product Development Process
I once hired someone to install such a process at my company. Like you, perhaps, I felt this was the best way to improve the flow of successful new products from our NPD pipeline. Turns out it doesn’t really work that way, as this study makes clear. Let’s walk through it.
The American Productivity and Quality Center (APQC) is known for its superb benchmarking. Their benchmarking methodology was once benchmarked against nine other benchmarking models (I’m not making this up) and came out on top. When APQC decided to benchmark NPD practices, they engaged two of the best subject matter experts available… Dr. Robert Cooper and Dr. Elko Kleinschmidt. So far, so good.
APQC examined 113 practices and found 12 particularly strong drivers of NPD success (shown in Figure 1.) I was impressed… correlations between 0.5 and 0.7. Note that six of these drivers are largely or completely “frontend” activities (done prior to the development stage) and another three concern effective teams.
Please also note what is conspicuously absent from this chart: In an obvious surprise to the researchers, the correlation for having a gate-review type of NPD process in place was less than 0.3. In the words of the authors, “The only expected best practice not connected to performance is having a new product process.”
You really can have an elite NPD process. Click here to learn how!
Wonderful. To boost your innovation in industrial markets, you’ve invested heavily in your NPD process and the best research shows it doesn’t drive success. So what do you do? Throw it out? I wouldn’t. I’d consider it a solid foundation and build upon it. If you correct two limitations common in most NPD processes (Figure 2) you can make it come alive to deliver great new products.
If any process in your company should be customer-driven, it should be the one that designs products for them. So try this at your next gate review: Ask project team members to write down how many hours they personally spent with customers vs. company colleagues. You may be surprised at how much time was used to attend meetings, complete forms, give presentations, etc.
But the real problem will likely be how little time they spent talking to customers. This is especially true in industrial markets – since the products may not be the same that we have around the house. Without insight from our industrial customers, two types of “fact errors” occur that lead to new product failure or mediocrity: wrong facts and missing facts. Wrong facts can come from anywhere, but the #1 culprit is the untested assumption. Someone thinks the customer would like this feature or thinks the competitor can’t match that technology. The thinker isn’t motivated to prove he is wrong, everyone else is too busy, and after a few internal meetings… a wrong assumption becomes a wrong fact.
A missing fact occurs when an important question is not answered. Of course, the overwhelming reason is that it’s never asked. We tend not to ask questions unless we think we’re in the company of someone who knows the answer. When serious customer interviews begin, though, teams test their assumptions, ask important questions and avoid most wrong and missing facts. Customer interviews make particular sense for industrial producers (Figure 3).
Most stage-gate processes also suffer from too much analytical thinking vs. discovery or “what-if” thinking. Analytical thinking looks for what has been done wrong; discovery thinking looks for what can be done right. You need both, but when put together in nearly any process–consider strategic planning, for instance–the analytical thinking crowds out the discovery thinking.
This leads to the third and most serious fact error… the undiscovered fact. These are quite different than missing facts. With missing facts, you may later say, “We really should have checked into that alternate technology or new consumer trend.” But with undiscovered facts it’s different. You’ll seldom be faulted for failing to discover a customer’s need they’ve neglected to mention. Yet more value is lost here than anywhere else because the opportunity to develop a blockbuster is missed.
And if you don’t capture these needs up-front, enormous project resources will be spent chasing commonplace and uninspired customer needs. Like any good problem-solving method innovation in industrial markets requires a well-defined problem. In this case, the problem is in the form of unaddressed customer needs.
If your stage-gate process is a good foundation, what should you build on top of it? Good training. I’m not talking about more training in how to fill in a gate review form. Teams need training in new skills… aggressively listening to customers… probing deeply to understand why their needs are important to them… collaborative brainstorming with customers to discover needs that neither party would have thought of separately.
Teams need training in benchmark testing, so they can find competitors’ weak spots and design against them. Teams need training in the use of quantitative interview data so they know what product designs will excite customers. And teams need training in how to price their new product so they won’t leave money on the table.
The pre-development gate is more important than all the other gates combined.
This may sound like a tall order, but the job can be simplified if you concentrate your training where it will do the most good: the front-end of the NPD process. I believe the pre-development gate is more important than all the other gates combined. Here’s why: For thirty years, studies have shown that most NPD failures occur from faulty work done before the development stage begins. And consider the golden rule of investment: Make your decision when you’ve gathered the most facts and spent the least money. Since most companies spend over 90% of their project costs after this gate, it is paramount.
My bottom line: Keep your stage-gate process and build on it. Your process probably asks good questions. But elite innovation in industrial markets requires more. Now make sure teams are trained to get good answers. Otherwise, you’re giving a test without providing the teaching. A failing grade will result.
If you want to learn more about what works in NPD, I recommend the APQC study referenced here, Improving New Product Development Performance and Practices (which can be purchased at www.apqc.org) and Dr. Cooper’s classic work, Winning at New Products. Further, if you’re interested in ramping up your NPD process, and boosting your innovation in industrial markets, read the following article, 12 Steps to Powerful New Product Development Process.
best place to buy liquid tadalafil buy cialis generic online 10 mg buy cialis in las vegas
https://tadalaccess.com/# cialis black in australia
comprar tadalafil 40 mg en walmart sin receta houston texas canadian cialis cialis 20 mg coupon
https://tadalaccess.com/# max dosage of cialis
buy cialis with dapoxetine in canada cialis erection tadalafil 5mg generic from us
https://tadalaccess.com/# vigra vs cialis
online cialis Tadal Access cialis price comparison no prescription
cialis testimonials cialis 40 mg reviews cialis with dapoxetine
https://tadalaccess.com/# cialis price walmart
cialis and adderall: tadalafil 40 mg with dapoxetine 60 mg – printable cialis coupon
can you drink wine or liquor if you took in tadalafil cialis where to buy in las vegas nv maximum dose of cialis in 24 hours
https://tadalaccess.com/# how long does cialis take to work
cialis pills canadian online pharmacy no prescription cialis dapoxetine cialis 20 mg duration
https://tadalaccess.com/# cialis purchase canada
cialis over the counter usa: best price for cialis – cialis before and after pictures
best price for tadalafil what does cialis do cialis mechanism of action
https://tadalaccess.com/# online cialis prescription
buy cialis free shipping cialis 20 mg from united kingdom mambo 36 tadalafil 20 mg
difference between sildenafil and tadalafil: TadalAccess – buy generic cialis
https://tadalaccess.com/# mambo 36 tadalafil 20 mg reviews
side effects cialis TadalAccess buying cialis online safely
buy tadalafil online paypal: buying cialis online safe – cialis 100mg
https://tadalaccess.com/# maximum dose of cialis in 24 hours
tadalafil 20mg (generic equivalent to cialis): Tadal Access – buy tadalafil no prescription
cialis 30 mg dose TadalAccess online tadalafil
https://tadalaccess.com/# vidalista 20 tadalafil tablets
cialis for blood pressure: cialis back pain – cialis for blood pressure
cialis manufacturer Tadal Access buy cialis united states
https://tadalaccess.com/# buy cialis online from canada
tadalafil cheapest online: Tadal Access – cialis free trial canada
cialis bathtub Tadal Access best time to take cialis
https://tadalaccess.com/# cialis free trial offer
cialis paypal canada: TadalAccess – how much does cialis cost with insurance
https://tadalaccess.com/# cialis reddit
when to take cialis for best results: TadalAccess – is tadalafil as effective as cialis
natural cialis buying cialis cialis online pharmacy australia
https://tadalaccess.com/# best place to buy tadalafil online
buying cialis generic: TadalAccess – benefits of tadalafil over sidenafil
canadian pharmacy cialis Tadal Access oryginal cialis
https://tadalaccess.com/# cialis cost at cvs
tadalafil online paypal: Tadal Access – cialis price per pill
cialis walmart TadalAccess cialis stories
buying cialis online safe: cialis interactions – what are the side effects of cialis
https://tadalaccess.com/# buy cialis online from canada
tadalafil no prescription forum cialis contraindications cialis generico
cialis professional: buy cialis online canada – pastillas cialis
https://tadalaccess.com/# cialis side effect
cialis sales in victoria canada when to take cialis 20mg does cialis shrink the prostate
https://tadalaccess.com/# purchase generic cialis
cialis in las vegas: Tadal Access – cialis usa
how long before sex should you take cialis can you drink alcohol with cialis tadalafil 5 mg tablet
https://tadalaccess.com/# best price on cialis
tadalafil tamsulosin combination: tadalafil online canadian pharmacy – tadalafil 20mg (generic equivalent to cialis)
buy cialis no prescription TadalAccess cheap cialis pills
https://tadalaccess.com/# tadalafil cheapest online
cialis after prostate surgery: TadalAccess – cialis available in walgreens over counter??
paypal cialis no prescription best reviewed tadalafil site tadalafil cost cvs
https://tadalaccess.com/# teva generic cialis
cialis for daily use side effects: TadalAccess – cialis dopoxetine
cialis max dose Tadal Access overnight cialis
https://tadalaccess.com/# cialis free trial voucher
cialis 20 mg best price: sildenafil vs tadalafil which is better – cialis for daily use side effects
is cialis a controlled substance TadalAccess how much tadalafil to take
https://tadalaccess.com/# tadalafil (tadalis-ajanta)
cialis manufacturer coupon lilly: Tadal Access – how much is cialis without insurance
maximpeptide tadalafil review Tadal Access prescription free cialis
https://tadalaccess.com/# cialis discount coupons
cialis patent expiration: cheapest cialis online – buy cialis online free shipping
does tadalafil lower blood pressure cialis paypal reddit cialis
https://tadalaccess.com/# tadalafil best price 20 mg
cialis cost per pill: Tadal Access – cialis generic online
https://tadalaccess.com/# cialis reddit
buy cialis online in austalia cialis vs.levitra how long before sex should you take cialis
cialis logo: buy generic cialiss – cialis softabs online
https://tadalaccess.com/# cialis dose
cialis definition Tadal Access is tadalafil peptide safe to take
canadian cialis online: TadalAccess – buy tadalafil online paypal
cialis online no prescription [url=https://tadalaccess.com/#]cialis priligy online australia[/url] cialis 20 mg price walgreens
https://tadalaccess.com/# cialis tadalafil
cialis or levitra: cost of cialis for daily use – cialis samples for physicians
cialis overnight shipping when does cialis go off patent cialis otc 2016
https://tadalaccess.com/# cialis for daily use dosage
difference between cialis and tadalafil: cialis 5mg best price – cialis over the counter in spain
super cialis cialis mechanism of action no prescription tadalafil
https://tadalaccess.com/# buy cialis in las vegas
cialis online without perscription: cialis information – when will generic cialis be available
online cialis australia TadalAccess canadian cialis
https://tadalaccess.com/# price of cialis at walmart
originalcialis: cialis manufacturer coupon free trial – tadalafil brand name
cialis dopoxetine TadalAccess comprar tadalafil 40 mg en walmart sin receta houston texas
https://tadalaccess.com/# tadalafil 5mg once a day
online cialis: Tadal Access – cialis canadian pharmacy
cialis 20 mg TadalAccess cialis free trial voucher
https://tadalaccess.com/# cialis indien bezahlung mit paypal
cialis coupon walmart: cialis free trial offer – purchase cialis on line
https://tadalaccess.com/# what doe cialis look like
cialis from india Tadal Access canadian cialis online
cialis 100mg review: TadalAccess – how much does cialis cost at cvs
https://tadalaccess.com/# cialis tadalafil discount
cialis online cheap Tadal Access u.s. pharmacy prices for cialis
buy cialis without prescription: cialis for daily use side effects – generic cialis super active tadalafil 20mg
https://tadalaccess.com/# buy cialis canada
prednisone rx coupon prednisone pill prednisone cream
PredniHealth: PredniHealth – PredniHealth
https://clomhealth.com/# cheap clomid no prescription
PredniHealth PredniHealth prednisone 10 mg over the counter
https://clomhealth.com/# where can i get cheap clomid without insurance
can i purchase clomid without prescription: Clom Health – where can i buy generic clomid without a prescription
buy prednisone 5mg canada order prednisone from canada PredniHealth
https://clomhealth.com/# cost of generic clomid tablets
prednisone 30 mg tablet: prednisone 50 mg for sale – 50mg prednisone tablet
get cheap clomid without a prescription can i order cheap clomid pill cheap clomid price
PredniHealth: PredniHealth – buy prednisone 50 mg
https://clomhealth.shop/# where can i get clomid
PredniHealth: PredniHealth – where can i buy prednisone without prescription
Amo Health Care Amo Health Care can you buy amoxicillin over the counter in canada
Amo Health Care: generic amoxicillin over the counter – amoxicillin where to get
https://clomhealth.com/# where buy generic clomid price
PredniHealth: prednisone 500 mg tablet – PredniHealth
prednisone 50 PredniHealth PredniHealth
can you buy amoxicillin uk: amoxicillin azithromycin – amoxicillin 500 mg online
https://clomhealth.com/# can i order generic clomid pill
200 mg prednisone daily: PredniHealth – PredniHealth
can i get clomid without dr prescription: Clom Health – cost cheap clomid now
buy amoxicillin 500mg capsules uk Amo Health Care Amo Health Care
https://amohealthcare.store/# amoxil pharmacy
PredniHealth: where to buy prednisone in australia – PredniHealth
where can i buy amoxicillin without prec: purchase amoxicillin 500 mg – amoxicillin 775 mg
https://zipgenericmd.com/# generic tadalafil
fast Viagra delivery: buy generic Viagra online – Viagra without prescription
order Viagra discreetly: best price for Viagra – order Viagra discreetly
doctor-reviewed advice doctor-reviewed advice modafinil 2025
https://zipgenericmd.com/# buy generic Cialis online
fast Viagra delivery: fast Viagra delivery – buy generic Viagra online
verified Modafinil vendors: modafinil pharmacy – modafinil pharmacy
best price for Viagra safe online pharmacy no doctor visit required
http://modafinilmd.store/# safe modafinil purchase
Viagra without prescription: trusted Viagra suppliers – best price for Viagra
safe online pharmacy: secure checkout Viagra – order Viagra discreetly
best price Cialis tablets order Cialis online no prescription reliable online pharmacy Cialis
http://maxviagramd.com/# discreet shipping
order Cialis online no prescription: discreet shipping ED pills – discreet shipping ED pills
secure checkout ED drugs order Cialis online no prescription secure checkout ED drugs
https://modafinilmd.store/# Modafinil for sale
safe modafinil purchase: verified Modafinil vendors – modafinil 2025
Modafinil for sale: Modafinil for sale – modafinil pharmacy
purchase Modafinil without prescription purchase Modafinil without prescription Modafinil for sale
secure checkout Viagra: legit Viagra online – same-day Viagra shipping
https://zipgenericmd.shop/# discreet shipping ED pills
cheap Cialis online: affordable ED medication – reliable online pharmacy Cialis
buy modafinil online: doctor-reviewed advice – Modafinil for sale
modafinil pharmacy legal Modafinil purchase buy modafinil online
https://zipgenericmd.shop/# FDA approved generic Cialis
modafinil legality: purchase Modafinil without prescription – buy modafinil online
modafinil legality: legal Modafinil purchase – buy modafinil online
affordable ED medication online Cialis pharmacy cheap Cialis online
http://zipgenericmd.com/# FDA approved generic Cialis
Modafinil for sale: modafinil pharmacy – modafinil pharmacy
modafinil 2025: legal Modafinil purchase – verified Modafinil vendors
reliable online pharmacy Cialis reliable online pharmacy Cialis buy generic Cialis online
buy modafinil online: doctor-reviewed advice – verified Modafinil vendors
order Cialis online no prescription: order Cialis online no prescription – best price Cialis tablets
order Cialis online no prescription: best price Cialis tablets – secure checkout ED drugs
http://pinupaz.top/# pinup az